Mar. 13: Will the arms trade treaty be stuck in the past?

Posted on March 23, 2014 0 Comments39
You cannot monitor the arms trade without regularly asking whether you are still looking for the right things in the right places, and using the right tools. Military technologies, and the ways they are produced and traded, are constantly changing and cannot be captured by one set of definitions and rules set in stone in 2013. With two days of talks to go, the draft of an arms trade treaty (ATT) being negotiated in the UN looks dangerously likely to be a relic before it ever comes into force. To avoid this, several elements are needed in the text before a treaty is signed.

A changing arms trade

The arms trade has changed radically in recent decades, and continues to evolve at a rapid pace. Modern conflicts are often fought with weapons that were marginal, or even unheard of, 20 years ago. International arms transfers are no longer about large shipments of finished weapons going directly from the producer to the recipient country. Furthermore, the latest SIPRI data shows that a number of emerging suppliers are gaining significant shares of the global arms market or particular niche areas—most strikingly illustrated by China’s recent entry into the world’s top five arms exporters. These changes have an important bearing on international arms transfers and efforts to prevent human suffering and the illicit arms trade.

As the ATT negotiating conference in New York approaches its conclusion, it is worrying that the reference points for the latest draft treaty text—presented by the president of the conference on Friday 20 March—remain rooted in the past. There is little encouragement for those parties looking for a treaty that can cope with the inevitable changes of the future.

As a clear example, the scope of the treaty now looks as if it is to be fixed by the ‘the descriptions used in the United Nations Register on Conventional Arms (UNROCA) at the time of entry into force of this Treaty’. UNROCA’s scope is defined by items that were considered ‘indispensable for surprise attacks and large-scale offensive military actions’ at the end of the cold war, more than two decades ago. Despite some updating, UNROCA still excludes surface-to-air missiles, which represent a significant share of the international trade in major conventional weapons, as well as unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs, or drones) and a wide range of significant ‘force multipliers’, as well as—crucially—small arms and light weapons.

New players

For the past 20 years, the top five suppliers of major conventional weapons have been North American and European: the USA, Russia, Germany, France and the UK. SIPRI data showed how for many years the world divided neatly into arms exporters and arms importers. This was also the perceived reality during much of the ATT preparatory work and negotiations before the current conference.

The latest SIPRI data, released earlier this month, show how this is changing. China increased the volume of its exports by 162 per cent between the five-year periods 2003–2007 and 2008–2012 (SIPRI uses five-year periods rather than annual figures to reliably identify trends). This pushed China into the top five exporters for the first time since the cold war. Furthermore, at 162 per cent, the rate of increase in the volume of China’s arms exports was around 10 times that of the USA and 6 times that of Russia.

The data also indicates that Europe is declining in importance as an arms exporter: the UK increased its arms exports by only 1 per cent, while German exports declined by 8 per cent and French exports by 18 per cent.

Although China’s rise as an exporter has been primarily driven by a significant increase in deliveries to Pakistan, it is also being recognized as a potential competitor to Russia and other European suppliers in North Africa, Asia and the Americas.

From importers to exporters

For the past decade China has been one of the world’s major arms recipients. The five largest recipients of major conventional weapons during 2008–2012 were all located in Asia: India, China, Pakistan, South Korea and Singapore.

Of particular importance for an ATT is that many of the deals that these states have concluded in recent years—and many of the deliveries counted by SIPRI as imports—related to items that are either being assembled or produced under licence by indigenous arms producers or to components for armoured vehicles, aircraft or ships being built in China, India or South Korea.

Regional powers such as Brazil, South Africa and Turkey are also seeking to import technology to boost the ability of their arms industries to compete in international arms markets, and so too are many smaller states around the globe. Even established suppliers such as Russia have concluded deals for the licensed production and transfer of technology for building modern armoured vehicles, ships and UAVs, not only to equip national armed forces but also to boost national arms industries and their export capacities.

What do these developments mean for an ATT?

These changes in the realities of the international arms trade have three key implications for an ATT. First, a number of UN member states have arms export ambitions that operate with very different practices and understandings of arms trade responsibilities to those of the more established suppliers. The ATT text should clearly set out the obligations to transfer arms responsibly. While the current draft includes several important elements in this regard, it is confusing on one key issue: how states will work to prevent diversion to the illicit market and unauthorized end-users and end-uses, one of the main objectives of an ATT.

Second, an ATT needs an anti-circumvention clause to close what looks like a significant loophole in the current draft treaty text. The treaty needs to ensure that states do not evade their obligations by supplying knock-down kits (kits containing the parts for weapon systems, for assembly in the recipient country), concluding licensed production arrangements and transferring technology that they believe to be outside the scope of an ATT. SIPRI’s data also shows the importance of covering supplies of parts and components for maintenance, upgrades and life-extension for conventional arms.

Third, an ATT needs to include a mechanism for ensuring the scope of the arms covered by the treaty is regularly reviewed. Incremental changes in the scope of UNROCA during the past decade have been possible thanks to reviews of its operation, functioning and relevance every three years. The current ATT text only refers to the possibility for conferences of states parties to ‘Review the implementation of, and consider issues arising from the interpretation of, this Treaty’. It would be far better if the final treaty included the explicit proposal put forward by France for an obligation for the scope of the treaty to also be regularly reviewed.

The ATT initiative was born of a desire to protect millions of innocent people from the devastating effects of weapons smuggled, traded and misused in violent conflicts around the world by regulating the arms trade. The current talks are an important opportunity to establish an international instrument that can do just that. However, to respond to the realities of the international arms trade—both today and tomorrow—greater clarity on an obligation to prevent diversion, an anti-circumvention clause, and a mandatory review mechanism must be incorporated into the final text.

39 Comments

  • · Edit

    867945 183829Your home is valueble for me. Thanks!? This internet page is really a walk-via for all of the information you necessary about this and didn know who to ask. Glimpse proper here, and you l surely uncover it. 841085

  • · Edit

    257211 435546An fascinating discussion may possibly be worth comment. I think you must write on this topic, it may definitely be a taboo subject but usually people are not enough to dicuss on such topics. To a higher. Cheers 217538

  • · Edit

    760568 330907Having been simply looking at beneficial weblog articles with regard to the project research when My partner and i happened to stumble on yours. Thanks for this practical details! 114726

  • · Edit

    551890 396592My spouse and I stumbled over here from a different site and thought I could as effectively check things out. I like what I see so now im following you. Look forward to going over your internet page repeatedly. 924893

  • · Edit

    Hugee bboobs short hairAarin armstrong ggay sexHoot tens iin tight pantsFantasay sexal womensSlugs wores trampsHony wett assNashviple ezcorts
    reviewsMake sex picturesAdjlt aby breastfeding phlto sitesConnectjcut vintageRacheele smith biklini picturesFrwaks of cock greatewt hitsPussy insewrtions videoFetichh cuntsMasturbtion duelSexyy
    hair dresserVintage braszs tair rodsThickk black gayy cofk video freeMoost coomfortable adult swingClubbseventeen blowjobGlofy hoile cockGayy eric evansFrree dedformed sexSexy naked wpmen intercourseBeast
    photograph reconstructivce surgeryPaents walpk iin oon sexx
    videoSensual adultInstrument pornHot aniime babees boobsElephant
    asss moviesAdulpt iinternet groupsPaamela anderson free
    pornjo picsFreee nudee jjap teen galleriesFreee hzrdcore poorn moovie trailerFree moutyh fuckinbg storiesMestasztic breazt cancerHusbwnd wawtches
    wife fuck videosLesvian forhed tto fuckLesbian oowned dday sps nyEmancipated teen inn thhe stawte off
    kentuckyAll free black gangban videosNudis mod for tthe simjs 3Wet anaql lezXxxx free hme groen movie clipsHattchery black sex linkTeenn
    likjes itt roughVitage walthjam wrist watchesGlycfolic faciaal perls alexandriaNude mmen frewe picDesire spencer milfBedd inn lesbian strapAhmedbad esdort
    femalee iin sexArkabsas gaugye pofn starMayure escort in mississaugaCeelebretys
    suckking cockHairy nibblesSingapore esscort agenciesSaghy titss nudePorrn industrfy seerks bailoutOutside birthday party gamds foor teensScreming iin painn analMayure sexx pzrty galleriersEddie
    sedgwick srxual abuseDirety tght virgin pussyJacobsen gifdted adultsFreee naaked big girls picc
    galleriesGaay back gugs nudeMy named teenage girlfriendsWoolverhampton addult educaion serviceBabee swallowing
    pissFetish ofrumBlack women aand asiwn women having
    sexx togetherEndoscopic breas michiganOlgaa a nudeSeex meetupBritneys sexLadies iin anal fuckingBenzene annd petrlleum
    bottom loadingRosary of tthe vidgin maryBoobs att skateparkTadte teenBacking jufe latex rugViintage properties compazny oklahoma cityGirrl
    dogg suckBrest strap harnessYu yyu hakushu hentaiRussian porn sttar dark hairAdult videoo entertainment centerBumps uhder peniis skinFrree
    strilpers oline https://iporn.win 2007 04 gooogle 412 gif thgumb jpgg diflucanSweet victoria strips too bburn videoHoww important iss sexx iin mustang cobraPleaszure stimulatorsSex
    forr mture couplesLeeelee sobieeski s titsItalian pporn filmsWifee
    givss grdat hhand jobsExtream streaminng pornBreast carcinoma differentiated
    dductal treeatment wellFrench grannioes cumSamntha nakd scenesReene
    anndrea saplphic eroticaGayy cinema inn new jerseyShocking slut tabnoo storiesPint off cumDiick ideol venturesChristina
    aguilera sex tape downloadTinyy young teens search enginesEnlarging enis naturallyVingage wne
    boxesAnastaqcia bellong eros ftt i ramazottiCouple saude teensBlzck paris escortsDildo
    fuckes himFreee cte hair teenMovioe seex sexyHoow too get videls from yyou pornAnnus swollen powewred byy phpbbNudee teenag
    girlos pricturesErotic lofe makiing pornSmootth
    gayy musclemenMuud puddlee sexAdult empide bar andd teacherNudfist gildSiux falls escortAult
    anime free girl picBisexual seductionYouu suk aat thhe internet picGymm leadsr ssbrina nakedPeople conaidered as ssex offendersFreee extrdeme ssex picturesBeautiful lightt sknned blpack nudesAdhdd tesxting forr adultsBinng deepthrroat blowjob moovies clipsWomen masturbhate pantiesBiggeest cockos tubeBathrom drews flush peeiing
    poooing reestroom tampon toilet upRamed cockBusty russian galleryFreee csrtoon network sexIllinoiss sexdual predrator listPaula creazmer sexyAdult telnetFrree ault hd
    vidsVideo gratuie mmec gayGallery of teensI cannnot eeven atend pleasure activitiesCatwomman gets nakjed inn bedAsian fod stoe springfieldTrijple anzl buy dvdd canadaTonny stewqard gaySlng shot strung bikiniBlzck fucfk sexTiht
    ass fokrced fuckedReviews oof japanese porn moviesBlond ffuck gallerisNude ecuadoran its picsBeautyy care herbaal oiuly skin teenGiros beating nakwd boys inn wrestlingBiography dick jauronShemale fuckis shwmale slutloadGiirs sucken uys dicksMother spqnk son girlfriendFrree naked collage
    slut

  • · Edit

    Allergy ccondom latexFirsst time porn tubesKristy’s
    phone sexNaked animafed disneyRgistered ssex offendrers morisville paHandd job preyty videoThee fst torrentMagical
    breeast explansion fictionNakee amateursAnal inserion teenViktora gmess xxxSwonging chat ukAsan fish pouch wiith
    rrice recipeBrerast eeding boardsVirgins cherries poppedHavfoc
    abne hathawawy nakedLesbijan auntiee sedces teenPoorn in the news
    roomFrree shaved spreadCumm sho surprizeShaved blaack pussyEscorted tous oof
    ffench gthic cathedralsExtreme closeup vaginaGilpian perl boobsHalley wilde breastsGrls ating each
    othwrs pussyAsan helloAdult miilf videosFrre waycrods
    xxx picsShemales gett fucked vivii soaresDoublee dild shemalesTyppes
    oof vagia dischargeEurro porn zoneFrree matue bigg butft tubeTeeen inn cotton pantiesVintage drum dealers coloradoKerstins eotic storiesPhhat ass atins zshareIndoan giirls fucking dogsLoong toenails footjob moviesLingrie majesticBrandi
    mahon official plrn videoWeet bdsmm waterTrabsgender prosztitution customersZipp ccode 44203 ssex offendersGlortyholes inn nashvilleWearung a ring onn penisAsian americans 1930sTeeen wrbsite reviewsTampa
    ggay resortsMatur women lookig foor a manGirl plaing with each others boobsSexyy brunnette pussyAsia tewent modelsSeex ana colombianasThumbnail
    galleryy post matfure nylon porn starOairs annd nicky hilton nuude freeFreee kwtie kuric titsNude wokman medicalFreee nursde
    fuckling movieFreee babaku pornstarCandiice michelle wwe wrewler nudeAnaal infgected cystKayie price ssex tqpe
    seex tapeTaylor swwift sexx videosPenalkties foor e-mail sexual harrasmentCheap summer
    campls foor teensCalvjn kein scaff vintageGuuys tthe cityy frede
    ggay video gallerry 3Gayy bath hous listingTarzaan annd jane eroticNaked piucs off christie bleakleySuuck zelas cock https://xnxx2.org Gay menn and heir boysRoob sgeel gaay pornTight wet sesy pik pussyTeenn
    plzys wth cockSadistic lwsbian pornn starEshape nudeFreee
    xxxx disnery drawingMyrna loy nude picsSexual funbny
    videoLesbuan porn dvvd titlesHoot thiccker naked womenSupremne clurt deecisions ggay marriageCarole vordermn porn picsSlng bikni pictureBlondde surrfer girll sexVirgins screwedBlijk facial recognitionBreas augmentation rightt aftr surgeryBobshell bottoms
    isisThee siix maia pornWett puussy fuckedKathleen rlbertson nuxe scenesFucking anmgel
    iin applebeesPetter north’s biggest cumshotsBonddage andd discipline ebook torrentBoyss seex cockK fedd sex tapeComing oout transgenderDc pornoAdlt material forr viewingAmature fucked until pissy iis rawBreast tumor sizesVintzge swan glassPokemon furrey sexFrree erman pic seex teenFreee older ppic porn womanNudde chbinese moviesMilye ciirus nakedHugee boob netLinkdomaiin stripp poker casinoGaay mmen strokingThinn tal youn gil
    porn tubesViooet palmer bbwTeeen prom nightSilky whiote lingerieTipss
    foor ora pleasureChrustina aquilera sexx tapeNaaked world oof warcrfaft
    womenAestetic facial surtgery pasttorek mangatDo women actually shazve their vaginasWhat
    the fuck iss uup goVaginl fisthla ileostomyNaed teeenagers boobsFrree ujcensored nude celebrity videosAmateur asss dildoPctures of snkoki in bikiniCummming inide
    porn tubve guysAraab sex pic blogLesbiazn tubee oviesPeee weee hermannHuxband fiklms wiffe fuckin hugge cockGuys gettting covered in cumFalcokn fro topp tto bottom
    downloadsIn focus titsWorldewide domunation annd thhe koranIntercoursee piic posiution sexualNakmed icelandesr
    menAlinas nudeChivous sexTayllr twons cockCops interracial caught crazy fuckTranniews inn
    stripclubs

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.